I’m really hot to get a small HD camcorder these days. I t would be great for lots of reasons, but mainly I am interested in using it for collecting multimedia content. The new HD camcorders are really amazing. For around $1000 you can get one that is fairly decent. Of course, I am pretty new to HD, and really, pretty new to video and audio, so I have been doing my homework.
I found a few cameras that I thought I would mention here. Three of them are pretty good candidates and the last one is out of my price range, and probably just too large for what I want to use it for. The Canon HV-20 is the cheapest at about $1000. It has a single sensor, with a color filter array (just like your digital SLR) but it can shoot in 24P mode, which makes it very attractive. It is also really really small. I have seen some sample footage from this camera, and it looks pretty nice for what you are paying. All I would need to add would be an XLR mic adapter, and a nice set of mics to get myself up and running. Of course there have been some complaints about the low-light performance, but that seems to be the big issue with all of the smaller consumer grade cams.
Another option I am seriously considering is the JVC HD Everio. This camera is also exceptionally small, and I like the black finish. The main difference with this camera is that it doesn’t use tapes. It has an internal 60 gig hard drive that stores your footage. To make this feasible, JVC decided to go with an MPEG-2 format (I guess their version is also somewhat new and better). With this format you can store up to 5 hours of full resolution footage. I would much rather use this type of system and burn my raw footage to DVD, than deal with all those little miniDV tapes. I have heard lots of mixed reviews about the HDD option, but it makes sense to me. I haven’t seen any sample footage yet, but I have heard that even with the MPEG compression, it is still very nice. The JVC goes for about $1500 and would also need an XLR and mic setup to make it sing.

The next step up in the price range is the Sony A1U. This thing was recommended to me by a couple of people over at MediaStorm.org. The A1U runs for about $2100, but comes complete with a mic and XLR inputs. It looks very similar to the old PD-150 that was really popular. The main drawback to the A1U (and the JVC) is that they don’t appear to have a 24P mode. I’m not sure how big of deal this is. I saw some sample comparisons from the Canon HV-20 showing off the difference between normal mode and 24P mode. There is certainly a difference, but I wonder how hard it would be to achieve the “film look” with filtering in post-production.

Right now I am pretty focused on the JVC. It really looks like a “Micah” sort of camera. The fourth camera in my list here is way out of my price range. It’s the Sony HVR-V1U. This thing was recently featured in a very interesting article by David Leeson from the Dallas Morning News. He has been using the camera to make frame grabs for still images. his article, which you can read here, is very enlightening, and I have to agree that we will be seeing more and more frame grabbing going on in the years to come.
The HVR-V1U looks incredible, but definitely too expensive and a little too large for my purposes at the moment. Has anyone out there had any experience with any of these cameras?





